Ice Cream Shop - 2014 Winners

Published May 29, 2014

Banana splits, waffle cones are fun, but it's all about the ice cream. Who's got the best?

2014 Winner

1. Polly's Freeze

Voters Love

"Polly's has been the place where you could go to laugh with friends, feel better after a bad day, celebrate a victory, or go..."  via Robin R.

Find It
5242 State Road 62 Georgetown IN 47122
2014 Runner-Up

2. The Comfy Cow

Voters Love

"Simply the finest, the funnest, the flirtiest & most fashionable ice cream experience in the world!!! Yes, Princes and..."  via David D.

Find It
1301 Herr Ln Louisville KY 40222
2014 Finalist

3. Homemade Ice Cream and Pie Kitchen

Voters Love

"Amazing place. This is far more than a ice cream shop. It is a bakery, dessert diner and more. Imagine fresh baked pies..." 

Find It
Multiple Locations
2014 Finalist

4. Valley Dairy Freeze

Voters Love

"Shelly even does ice cream parties and they are awesome! You should use her for your event. She has every topping imaginable..."  via Kim D.

Find It
10300 Deering Road Louisville KY
2014 Finalist

5. Graeter's Ice Cream

Voters Love

"A co-worker mentioned that Graeter's was his favorite ice cream, from the years when he lived in Cincy. I had never been to..." 

Find It
Multiple Locations
Contest Overview
  • 20,393
    Total Votes
  • 7,710
  • 119

The 2014 Louisville A-List awards are based on more than 20,000 votes from local Louisville-area experts.

See the full results →

Get more from the Louisville A-List
Arts and Entertainment
Beauty and Wellness
Cheap Eats
Great Meals
Specialty Food and Drink
Contest Tools
Business Owners
Top Voters
FAQs / Help
Contest Rules
How it Works - Deals
CityVoter Blog
The Louisville A-List features more than 2,450 businesses competing for title of Louisville's best.

Connect with Louisville A-List